Could your next hire be a threat to your team culture?
- Brian Evans MPM
- 7 days ago
- 1 min read
I was reading a piece on Google News about toxic leaders, and it reinforced something I’ve learned the hard way: in Recruitment, you don’t “discover” toxicity after Hiring — you either screen for it early, or you end up paying for it later through attrition, fear-based culture, and stalled performance.
What I look for now isn’t charisma. It’s patterns.
A few signals that consistently matter in interviews and reference checks:
- How they talk about past teams. If every story has a villain and they’re always the hero, that’s rarely a coincidence.
- Their relationship with accountability. Strong leaders can name what they got wrong without turning it into a PR answer.
- How they handle power. Do they default to control (“tight management”) or clarity (expectations, coaching, feedback loops)?
- Evidence of talent outcomes. Did high performers grow under them—or leave? And why?
- Consistency across stakeholders. I pay close attention when peers and former direct reports describe two very different people.
The uncomfortable truth: toxic leaders often interview well. The goal is to design a process that makes it hard to perform and easy to reveal.
How do you pressure-test leadership behavior in your Hiring process—especially for senior roles?
Comments